About Pizza Pete's
Upper West Side's beloved neighborhood pizzeria — serving classic New York-style pizza on Columbus Avenue for decades.
A Neighborhood Institution
Pizza Pete's has been a fixture on Columbus Avenue in the Upper West Side for decades. What started as a small neighborhood slice shop has grown into one of Manhattan's most beloved pizzerias, known for our classic New York-style pizza and friendly service.
Located at 528 Columbus Avenue between 85th and 86th Street, we're the go-to spot for locals craving a perfect slice. Our pizza is made with fresh dough daily, premium mozzarella, and our signature sauce — the same recipe that's kept customers coming back for generations.
We're proud to serve the Upper West Side community with a wide variety of pizzas — from classic cheese and pepperoni to our famous fresh mozzarella slice, Sicilian pies, grandma slices, and buffalo chicken. Every pie is made to order with quality ingredients.
Beyond pizza, we offer fresh salads, calzones, garlic knots, pasta dishes, and a full catering menu for parties, corporate events, and gatherings of any size. Order online for 10% off and free delivery!
What We Offer
🍕 Classic New York-Style Pizza
Our signature thin-crust pizza with the perfect fold. Made with fresh dough daily, premium mozzarella, and our family-recipe sauce. Available by the slice or as a whole pie.
🧀 Fresh Mozzarella Pies
Our fresh mozzarella pizza is a customer favorite. Premium fior di latte mozzarella, San Marzano-style sauce, and a drizzle of olive oil on our classic crust.
🍕 Sicilian & Grandma Slices
Thick-crust Sicilian square pies and classic Grandma slices — a New York staple. Available with fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, and more toppings.
🍗 Buffalo Chicken & Specialty Pies
Our famous buffalo chicken slice is a must-try! We also offer white pizza, pepperoni, veggie, and build-your-own pies with your favorite toppings.
🥗 Salads, Calzones & More
Beyond pizza, we serve fresh salads, calzones, garlic knots, pasta dishes, and more. Something for everyone in the family!
🚚 Order Online — 10% Off + Free Delivery
Order online and get 10% off your entire order plus free delivery to the Upper West Side and surrounding neighborhoods. Quick, easy, and delicious!
Come Visit Us Today!
528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024 • (212) 787-3153